Closing Arguments in Karen Read Murder Retrial
Canton, Massachusetts — The retrial of Karen Read, a 45-year-old woman accused of killing her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O’Keefe, reached a pivotal moment on Friday as attorneys delivered their closing arguments. Read has pleaded not guilty to charges, including second-degree murder and vehicle manslaughter while driving under the influence, in connection with O’Keefe’s death during a snowstorm on January 29, 2022. The case, previously tried with a hung jury, is now back in Norfolk Superior Court, where emotions are running high.
Prosecutor’s Arguments Highlighted Reckless Actions
Prosecutor Hank Brennan stressed the gravity of Read’s actions that night, painting a picture of a relationship ending in tragedy. He described the scene where O’Keefe lay helpless, asserting that Read—angry and intoxicated—made a conscious decision to leave the scene instead of calling for help. "She made a decision in her Lexus…she drove away," Brennan said, underscoring the severity of her choices amid the chaos of a snowstorm.
Data from Read’s SUV and testimony from first responders supported the prosecution’s timeline, with Brennan claiming that Read was aware of her involvement. He noted that she reportedly admitted, “I hit him,” describing the aftermath of that fateful decision.
Defense Calls for Caution and Reasonable Doubt
In a contrasting approach, defense attorney Alan Jackson argued that there was no collision to speak of. He highlighted issues with the investigation, claiming that bias and misconduct tainted the evidence. Jackson maintained that O’Keefe’s injuries were consistent with those from a dog bite or a physical fight, suggesting that he may have been attacked by a German Shepherd prior to his death.
“The fact is, the injuries are not from a vehicle impact,” Jackson posited, echoing the defense’s line of reasoning that questioned the integrity of the prosecution’s case.
A Case of Conflicting Narratives
As the jury deliberates, both sides face the challenge of unpacking a complex narrative involving intoxication, relationship dynamics, and the dark consequences of a single night. With the trial drawing to a close, the question now remains: will the jury find reasonable doubt, or will they hold Read accountable for her actions?
As this case continues to unfold, more updates will follow.
Focuses on crime, public safety, and regional events.
Bio: Marcus is a community-based journalist passionate about reporting impactful stories that matter most to readers.