In the world of television, spin-offs are like those surprise bonus tracks on your favorite albums—when done right, they can add new depth and joy to a beloved series. Fans often crave more of their favorite characters and worlds, prompting networks to take the plunge into expansion. But let’s face it: not every spin-off is destined for success. From beloved characters on new adventures to entirely new concepts that barely resemble the original, the results can be hit or miss. In this increasingly crowded marketplace, let’s explore the ultimate ranking of TV spin-offs: which ones hit the mark and which ones faltered?

1. Better Call Saul

This prequel to Breaking Bad dives into the backstory of Jimmy McGill, a small-time lawyer who eventually becomes the shifty Saul Goodman we all know. What makes Better Call Saul a standout is its character depth and moral complexity. Showrunner Vince Gilligan and co-creator Peter Gould have crafted an engaging narrative that not only pays homage to the original series but also establishes its unique identity. A blend of drama and dark humor makes this spin-off both critically acclaimed and a fan favorite, proving that great storytelling can elevate even the most unpredictable characters.

2. Frasier

After the beloved character Frasier Crane left Cheers, he found new life in Frasier, a sitcom that explored the nuances of family, friendship, and the quirks of being a radio psychiatrist. This spin-off brilliantly maintained the charm of its predecessor while crafting a new narrative atmosphere that showcased Frasier’s sophistication and misadventures with family and friends. The clever writing, talented cast, and fresh settings made Frasier not just a successful spin-off, but a hallmark of television comedy.

3. The Mandalorian

Set in the expansive Star Wars universe, The Mandalorian has been a game-changer for Disney+. This spin-off succeeded in blending new characters and storylines with the rich lore of Star Wars. Featuring the endearing Baby Yoda, or Grogu as we’ve come to know him, the series caters to both die-hard fans and newcomers alike. Its cinematic quality and engaging storytelling have sparked renewed interest in the franchise, affirming that spin-offs can yield blockbuster status if they connect with audiences on a deeper level.

4. The Office: US

While The Office remains an all-time favorite sitcom, its spin-off, The Office: US, made a splash with its unique takes on workplace comedy. Though it didn’t capitalize on the original’s characters, the U.S. version succeeded in creating its own hilarious and relatable cast. With memorable moments, iconic quotes, and innovative comedic styles, it managed to charm a wide audience and build a legacy of its own. However, while it’s a beloved series in its own right, some fans still feel it couldn’t quite capture the magic of the UK original.

5. Angel

Following the dark vampire from Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel took the supernatural drama to new heights. This spin-off introduced viewers to a richer narrative filled with complex relationships and moral dilemmas. As Angel seeks redemption for his dark past while helping those in need, the show explores themes of loyalty, love, and the struggle against one’s own nature. Although not as universally acclaimed as Buffy, Angel built a devoted fan base and remains a cherished addition to the genre.

6. Joey

This Friends spin-off focused on the lovable character Joey Tribbiani, attempting to capture his charm while exploring life in Los Angeles. Unfortunately, it stumbled along the way. Although some moments resonate with fans, it failed to achieve the sustained chemistry of the original ensemble cast and lacked the same depth of storytelling. Joey serves as a cautionary tale that sometimes the best characters are better left in their original environments.

7. The Conners

This Roseanne spin-off emerged after the controversial exit of its titular character, Roseanne Barr. Centered on the conniving family without their matriarch, The Conners maintains the heart of the original series while focusing on broader contemporary issues. Although it lacks the punch of its predecessor, it’s commendable how it transitioned from the drama that engulfed the original into a series that explores real-life challenges with humor and sincerity.

8. How I Met Your Father

With nostalgia for 2000s sitcoms at an all-time high, How I Met Your Father sought to capture the essence of its predecessor. Starring Hilary Duff, this spin-off revisits the dating dilemmas of a new generation in a similar narrative style. While its potential attracted interest, it faced criticism over its lack of originality and character depth. Although it has its charm, it serves as a reminder that imitating a successful formula without innovation may not hit the mark.

The Spin-off Landscape: What We Learned

Television spin-offs offer a rich tapestry of storytelling possibilities, ranging from phenomenal successes to significant missteps. The ultimate ranking of TV spin-offs clearly highlights that the best spin-offs honor their roots while bravely forging their own paths. When they successfully blend character depth, humor, and unique narratives, they connect with audiences on a profound level. The magic often lies in how well writers take familiar characters and place them in new, unexpected scenarios.

What are your thoughts on the spin-offs you’ve seen? Which ones stood out to you, both positively and negatively? Share your experiences in the comments below!

Jamie Li

Covers viral stories, pop culture, and breaking celebrity news.

Bio: Jamie has a sharp eye for what’s buzzing online, tracking social media trends and entertainment headlines around the clock.